What story are you talking about that Reggie has told consistently? Do you mean the one where he said David accused him of stealing some money and "After that I don't remember nothing else. I remember waking up in the woods"?

Reggie's story doesn't jive. One minute he's saying he woke up in David's car being molested, and the next minute he doesn't remember anything before waking up in the woods. Which is it?

You're obviously siding with Reggie, probably because he's a family member or close friend. You're not helping him by making excuses for his behavior. It stunts his character, and character, not circumstances, makes the man. If you care about Reggie, help him to step up and build his character. Help him be a man.