People's right shouldn't be subject to the will of the people. Yes, majority should rule, but the rights of the minority need to be protected. Amendment One walks all over the rights of the minority, just like the 1875 amendment that prohibited interracial marriages.
And don't give me the moral crap. We're not all Christians, and thus should not have Christian morals forced upon us. One person's rights end where the next person's rights begin, and a union between two men or two women who commit to a lifetime partnership in no way infringes upon the marriage rights of a man and a woman. And if it was just about marriage, you wouldn't have voted to outlaw the recognition of civil unions too.
More information about formatting options