Sierra Club report warns data center growth could reverse 15 years of climate progress

Cement carbon dioxide emissions quietly double in 20 years (Photo: Pixabay)

RALEIGH, NC (WWAY) — A new report from the Sierra Club warns that growing electricity demand from artificial intelligence data centers could reverse 15 years of progress in reducing carbon emissions while driving up energy costs for customers.

The report, titled “Artificial Intelligence, Real Pollution,” was released Tuesday and examines how the rapid expansion of data centers could increase pollution as utility companies turn to natural gas and other fossil fuels to meet rising energy demands.

According to the report, carbon dioxide emissions from the U.S. electric sector could reach 2.3 billion tons annually by 2030, returning to levels last seen around 2011.

The environmental organization says nearly 250 gigawatts of new natural gas power plants are planned or under construction nationwide, with data center demand contributing to that expansion.

In North Carolina, the report raises concerns about Duke Energy’s changing emissions projections.

According to data from the nonprofit RMI cited in the report, Duke Energy Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress projected in 2023 that their carbon emissions would decrease by 50% between 2025 and 2035.

However, updated projections in 2026 instead showed emissions increasing by 16% over that period.

The Sierra Club said those projections were based on earlier utility energy plans and do not account for the new Carbon Plan approved by the North Carolina Utilities Commission on Monday.

“Clean energy and affordability are a package deal, and Duke is failing its customers as utility executives prioritize expensive new gas-burning plants and delay coal plant closures to serve data centers,” said Mikaela Curry, the Sierra Club’s Beyond Coal campaign manager in North Carolina.

The report also warns that increased reliance on natural gas could expose customers to higher electricity bills while contributing to air pollution in communities near power plants.

To address those concerns, the Sierra Club is calling for stronger regulations and greater transparency for data center developers and utility companies.

The organization recommends expanding renewable energy production, including tripling solar and doubling wind generation on the nation’s electric grid.

According to the report, those investments could reduce carbon emissions by 25% compared to 2025 levels and lower average annual electricity costs by more than $5 billion nationwide compared with a business-as-usual scenario, even with moderate data center growth.

The Sierra Club also argues that voluntary efforts by data center companies to reduce their environmental impacts have been limited and that additional oversight is needed.

“For over a decade, communities, advocates, and changemakers have stepped up to protect our air and water from toxic pollution and taken swift action to protect our planet from climate change,” said Holly Bender, the Sierra Club’s chief program officer.

“But now, these artificial intelligence data centers and their power demand threatens to undo all of the work we’ve accomplished.”

The findings come as North Carolina utilities plan for growing electricity demand while working toward the state’s goal of achieving net-zero carbon emissions by 2050.

The Sierra Club is urging state lawmakers, regulators and utility companies to adopt stronger policies to limit pollution and protect customers from potential increases in energy costs.

The report’s projections represent potential outcomes based on future energy development, rather than emissions increases that have already occurred.

Categories: NC, News